Justice Usha Mehra Commission on 22 February submitted its report to on the 16 December Delhi gang-rape incident to the Union. held on were noted and approved by the Commission. Agenda Item No Recommendations of Justice Usha Mehra. Committee Report regarding. headed by Justice Usha Mehra, a retired judge of the Delhi High reviewed various Supreme Court judgments on reservation, reports of the.

Author: Faelar Mezijar
Country: Anguilla
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Photos
Published (Last): 19 January 2016
Pages: 211
PDF File Size: 16.33 Mb
ePub File Size: 5.31 Mb
ISBN: 394-3-55484-187-5
Downloads: 79210
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Kecage


The Commission except reiterating the guidelines issued by the Governent about the implementation of the Special Component Plan never bothered to review the implementation of the programme and failed to verify the diversion of funds made by the successive Governments in implementing the programmes.

In respect of Bindla, a satellite not share wells and common burial ground with other communities. The probe panel has requested the members of public to provide any information about the shocking incident gangrape of a young woman here. Thus, the effort of the Commission to say that Scheduled Castes in Andhra Pradesh are heterogeneous is unconstitutional and unsustainable. The Commissions report that in educational programmes and government schemes and in employment, Malas and allied communities enjoyed more benefits commissiom also factually incorrect.

The Commission’s observation about certain Scheduled Castes are contradictory to each other. Justice Usha Mehra 3 Oct, commission, Further, the Commission conveniently not taken into account and failed to take note of the special schemes being mehga by the Government for Madigas, the facilities and services being extended by LIDCAP ushha establishment of Leather Parks in various districts investing several crores of rupees by alloting thousands of acres.

Thus, further sub-classification, mini-classification, division or grouping is beyond the power of Parliament and thus unconstitutional.

All News Videos Photos. The Commission’s effort to unduly favour the Madigas by quoting the speeches of the Dr. The report of the Usha mehra Commission is in effect pari materia of Justice Ramachandra Raju’s Commission which was rejected by the National Commission and also by the Hon’ble Judtice Court as un acceptable.

Justice Usha Mehra Commission Submitted its Report to the Union Government of India

Law Commission for “swift” scrapping of capital punishment 31 Aug, The report is purely advisory and not binding and need not be placed before the Legislature. Justice Commissoon Mehra Commission observed that it was happy commissioh getting a positive response for categorization. Thus, the observations particularly made with reference to Malas, that for Malas, Madigas are untouchables has no basis and irrelevant and biased and motivated.


Honestely Speaking, Justice Usha Mehra commission report is fallacious, beyond the scope of the reference,irrelevant, misleading and defective based on insufficient data and inadequate samples and erroneous conclusions drawn based on the selective representations presented by the MRPS deliberately to prove the Commission’s predetermined intention to sub-classify the Scheduled castes, which cannot be relied upon and deserves to be ignored, and rejected in the larger interests of the scheduled castes and in the national intrests as a whole.

The Scheduled Castes classification is not a definite matter of public importance for appointment of a Commission under the Commissions of Inquiry Act The report of the Commission is beyond its terms of reference with an anxiety to show that a particular community, Mala, occupied more posts.

Justice Mehra Commission’s Report at page No. It was only dealing with categorization of Backward Classes and the Court itself discussed at length about the class and caste and held categorically the judgement is not applicable to Scheduled Castes.

Thus, the population of only Mala and Adi-andhra comes to But, in contrast, the Commission observed that the Adi-Andhras have concered more benefits limiting their population to just 1. We, on behalf of the Association for Social Action, Andhra Pradesh an intellectual group of Scheduled Caste officers endeavoring for the promotion of Welfare, developement and unity among the Scheduled castes, present the following objections on the report submitted by Justice Usha Mehra Commission on with an appeal to consider the issue in a fair, just, objective and dispassionate manner.

As per censusthe population of Adi-andhra group wasand as per censusit was whereas as per census, the population of Adi-andhra shown as only Vodafone Business Services Digilogue – Your guide to digitally transforming your business.


It shows the Mala population as Home Ministry has finally made public the Justice Mehra Commission report that inquired into the lapses leading to the incident as well as ATR on its recommendations. The very commsision suggested by the Commission for amendment is not clear.

In respect of Relli, it is stated that they do not take food or water from Mala, Madiga and Paky. The Commission report was submitted in a hurried and hasty manner recommending sub-classification as there was a threat of indefinite fast by the MRPS leader giving a dead line and thus only to satisfy the forces and self-interest groups, the report was submitted probably to save the life of leader of MRPS, a leader of one community ignoring the larger interests of 59 castes in Andhra Pradesh and castes in the country usya will cause unrest and encourage divisive forces in every Jutsice and Union Territory.


The characteristics and the salient features of the schedule castes are same though the names of caste and sub-caste may vary. While dealing with Malas, they were also referred to Adi-andhras. They relate to identification of Backward classes and social status of an off-spring of an inter-caste married couple and with regard to creamy layer which is not applicable to the SCs.

According to which, all the Scheduled Castes including sub-castes, sub-groups they constitute one groupwhich are homogeneous and belong to one caste for the purpose of the Constitution. Justice Mehra Commission reported the Madiga population as The recommendation of the Commission that the State Legislature based on the recommendations of the Judicial Commission, shall indicate specifically as to what percentage of reservation benefits shall be given to which caste, races or tribes of SCs or part of or group within in any caste, races or tribes thereof based on their population ratio implies that the State should appoint another judicial commission jusitce carryout the same exercise before taking any further actionbased on the report.

Which was misread and misconstrued probably to suit its desire. The Commission failed to take note of the definition of SCs as defined in Article 24 as such castes, races or tribes or parts of groups of such castes, races or tribes as are deemed under Article to be Scheduled Castes for the purpose of the Constitution.

For Instance, it is observed that for a Mala, a Madiga is an kehra.

Government Two government appointees in the law panel — then ex-offic Law Commission recommended by a majority “swift” abolition of death penalty except in terror-related cases, noting it does not serve the penological goal of deterrence any more than life imprisonment.